Klara ja aurinko

nicknicknicknick@bookwyrm.social reviewed Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro

Klara and the Sun

4 stars

Content warning Spoilers

1) "When we were new, Rosa and I were mid-store, on the magazines table side, and could see through more than half of the window. So we were able to watch the outside – the office workers hurrying by, the taxis, the runners, the tourists, Beggar Man and his dog, the lower part of the RPO Building. Once we were more settled, Manager allowed us to walk up to the front until we were right behind the window display, and then we could see how tall the RPO Building was. And if we were there at just the right time, we would see the Sun on his journey, crossing between the building tops from our side over to the RPO Building side."

2) "'Housekeeper,' I said. 'I have a plan, a special plan to help Josie. I'm not able to speak openly about it. But if I can go to the city with Josie and her mother, I may have the opportunity to carry it out.' 'Plan? Listen, AF. You make things worse, I fuck come dismantle you.'"

3) "'I think I hate Capaldi because deep down I suspect he may be right. That what he claims is true. That science has now proved beyond doubt there's nothing so unique about my daughter, nothing there our modern tools can't excavate, copy, transfer. That people have been living with one another all this time, centuries, loving and hating each other, and all on a mistaken premise. A kind of superstition we kept going while we didn't know better. That's how Capaldi sees it, and there's a part of me that fears he's right. Chrissie, on the other hand, isn't like me. She may not know it yet, but she'll never let herself be persuaded. If the moment ever comes, never mind how well you play your part, Klara, never mind how much she wishes it to work, Chrissie just won't be able to accept it. She's too... old-fashioned. Even if she knows she's going against the science and the math, she still won't be able to do it. She just won't stretch that far. But I'm different. I have... a kind of coldness inside me she lacks. Perhaps it's because I'm an expert engineer, as you put it. This is why I find it so hard to be civil around people like Capaldi. When they do what they do, say what they say, it feels like they're taking from me what I hold most precious in this life. Am I making sense?'"

4) "'Mr. Capaldi believed there was nothing special inside Josie that couldn't be continued. He told the Mother he'd searched and searched and found nothing like that. But I believe now he was searching in the wrong place. There was something very special, but it wasn't inside Josie. It was inside those who loved her.'"

5) "'Before you go, Manager. I must report to you one more thing. The Sun was very kind to me. He was always kind to me from the start. But when I was with Josie, once, he was particularly kind. I wanted Manager to know.' 'Yes. I'm sure the Sun has always been good to you, Klara.'"

Juhana reviewed Klara ja aurinko by Kazuo Ishiguro

Ovatko ystävät sähköisiä?

4 stars

Klara ja aurinko oli lukukokemukseltaan kuin eräänlainen tulevaisuuden Candide, jossa kirjan päähenkilönä toimiva keinotekoinen ystävä Klara tulkitsee ympäröivää (pientä) maailmaansa naivistisella mutta terävällä otteella. Klara o(s)tetaan perheeseen huolehtimaan äidin tytärtään, joka on muuttunut sairaalloiseksi geeniterapian yhteydessä. Samalla kun Klara tulee osaksi perhettä, hän pääsee osalliseksi perheen salaisuuksiin.

Tarinallisesti teos on kuvaileva. Paljon havaintoja ympäröivästä maailmasta, mutta niiden taustat jää naiiville Klaralle useimmiten epäselviksi, joka toimii kirjan ainoana kerronnallisena subjektina. Lukija useimmiten joutuu lukemaan rivien välistä hahmottaakseen niiden todellista luonnetta. Perheen ympärille on kyhätty erinäisiä juonellisia lankoja, jotka heijastelevat uusien teknologioiden vaikutuksia yksilöihin ja yhteiskuntiin. Mitenkä paljon geenimanipulointi jakaa ihmisiä voittajiin ja häviäjiin? Onko keinoystävien ja ihmisten välinen suhde lopulta vain väliaikaista? Nämä kysymykset heijastelevat myös nykyaikaa ja ihmisyyttä. Yhteiskunnallisten epävakauksien kohdalle tarjotaan vastaukseksi uskoa: Klaralla on miltei uskonnollinen suhde kaikkivoipaiseen aurinkoon, ja päätyy tekemään jopa radikaaleja ratkaisuja auringon suosiollisuuden eteen. Mutta miten paljon uskolla voi vaikuttaa asioihin?

Kirjana …

Klara ja aurinko oli lukukokemukseltaan kuin eräänlainen tulevaisuuden Candide, jossa kirjan päähenkilönä toimiva keinotekoinen ystävä Klara tulkitsee ympäröivää (pientä) maailmaansa naivistisella mutta terävällä otteella. Klara o(s)tetaan perheeseen huolehtimaan äidin tytärtään, joka on muuttunut sairaalloiseksi geeniterapian yhteydessä. Samalla kun Klara tulee osaksi perhettä, hän pääsee osalliseksi perheen salaisuuksiin.

Tarinallisesti teos on kuvaileva. Paljon havaintoja ympäröivästä maailmasta, mutta niiden taustat jää naiiville Klaralle useimmiten epäselviksi, joka toimii kirjan ainoana kerronnallisena subjektina. Lukija useimmiten joutuu lukemaan rivien välistä hahmottaakseen niiden todellista luonnetta. Perheen ympärille on kyhätty erinäisiä juonellisia lankoja, jotka heijastelevat uusien teknologioiden vaikutuksia yksilöihin ja yhteiskuntiin. Mitenkä paljon geenimanipulointi jakaa ihmisiä voittajiin ja häviäjiin? Onko keinoystävien ja ihmisten välinen suhde lopulta vain väliaikaista? Nämä kysymykset heijastelevat myös nykyaikaa ja ihmisyyttä. Yhteiskunnallisten epävakauksien kohdalle tarjotaan vastaukseksi uskoa: Klaralla on miltei uskonnollinen suhde kaikkivoipaiseen aurinkoon, ja päätyy tekemään jopa radikaaleja ratkaisuja auringon suosiollisuuden eteen. Mutta miten paljon uskolla voi vaikuttaa asioihin?

Kirjana tätä on vaikea arvioida. Kirjan lopullinen viesti jää mysteeriksi. Se voi toisaalta olla kirjan tarkoitus; mitään lopullisia totuuksia ihmisyydestä ei kirjoiteta, voi vain esittää havaintoja ja lukijan tulkintoja niistä. Klara oli kuitenkin kertojana niin sympaattinen, että oli helppo eläytyä hänen maailmaansa ja yrityksiinsä tasapainottaa sitä, vaikka teki kipeää.

L.A. reviewed Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro

Klara And The Sun

5 stars

This was an interesting read and given that I have not read any of the author's other works, I was not quite sure what I was getting into. (Though, I have watched Remains Of The Day)

This book felt simple and yet complex. The simplicity was in the narrator: an AI or artificial friend who seems a bit naive and limited to her programming being a friend with a sick child. The complexity was in everything surrounding the two of them that wasn't said or maybe not said too loudly.

It is scifi and post apocalyptic, but you would not know it first delving into the story. Klara is a unique narrator but unreliable for such interesting times. Her unique view of the world drives the narrative most of the time.

The uses of faith, family, culture, society, technology and relationships really fleshes out the story and …

This was an interesting read and given that I have not read any of the author's other works, I was not quite sure what I was getting into. (Though, I have watched Remains Of The Day)

This book felt simple and yet complex. The simplicity was in the narrator: an AI or artificial friend who seems a bit naive and limited to her programming being a friend with a sick child. The complexity was in everything surrounding the two of them that wasn't said or maybe not said too loudly.

It is scifi and post apocalyptic, but you would not know it first delving into the story. Klara is a unique narrator but unreliable for such interesting times. Her unique view of the world drives the narrative most of the time.

The uses of faith, family, culture, society, technology and relationships really fleshes out the story and gives the quiet parts more weight.

Maybe I'll try another book by this author. I really enjoyed this.

King Death of the Scurvy Rats reviewed Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro

I needed time to emotionally process this book after reading it

5 stars

I'd never read anything from Ishiguro before. I picked it up, read the entire thing in one day from dawn til dusk, and found it such an easy read. I didn't even feel particularly engrossed I just knew that I was enjoying it and I wanted to read on. I was unfamiliar with Ishiguro's craftmanship and was unwittingly sucked into his trap

I won't spoil anything, but I spent a good hour or so in silent reflection after finishing the book, and for the week that followed I barely worked and spent a lot of time thinking about the book and reading reviews to try and figure out what on earth had just happened to me

I'd never read anything from Ishiguro before. I picked it up, read the entire thing in one day from dawn til dusk, and found it such an easy read. I didn't even feel particularly engrossed I just knew that I was enjoying it and I wanted to read on. I was unfamiliar with Ishiguro's craftmanship and was unwittingly sucked into his trap

I won't spoil anything, but I spent a good hour or so in silent reflection after finishing the book, and for the week that followed I barely worked and spent a lot of time thinking about the book and reading reviews to try and figure out what on earth had just happened to me

Noisy Deadlines reviewed Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro

Missed Opportunities

2 stars

The premise is beautiful, it hints at deep reflections about being human, but it didn't work for me. The dialogues were super weird and unnatural, they really bothered me. I missed more exploration of the technology behind the Artificial Friends (AF) and how they worked. Was Klara all mechanical? Was she an android? I wasn't convinced that AF's would find mystical significance in the Sun. The story hints at several themes but never really goes deep: environmental pollution, empathy, robots taking over human jobs, loneliness, gene editing, social class privilege. The plot is super simple and predictable, and the ending was very bleh. Probably not my thing.

Subjects